September 9, 2009

Five Random Thoughts (Adaptation ideas, Red Tornado, Iron Man)

by JL Franke

Quote of the week:

<I don't suppose you've heard of The Joker?>

<N-no, Master. He sounds...amusing.>

<He isn't amusing. He's probably the single most psychotic killer America has produced. And that, my friend, is saying something.>

(from Batman Confidential)

  1. Note to the folks of the new DC Entertainment: you want to take better advantage of your comic books in other media? Sell The Northlanders as an HBO series/miniseries. The series provides a variety of different stories, but a series just starring Sven could work.

  2. Note to the folks of the new Disney-held Marvel Entertainment: you want to take better advantage of your comic books in other media? Make Incognito into a feature film. It's way more adaptable to the screen than Wanted ever hoped to be.

  3. The latest issue of The Invincible Iron Man bears the logo proclaiming it the Eisner winner for Best New Series. If I were feeling more destructive, I would take a black marker to that logo. Tony Stark is getting dumber ever so sloooooooooooooowwwwwwly. And so is the reader. I have fewer brain cells thanks to reading this issue. It's a shame, because this was such a promising title with a writer who clearly had a concept of Iron Man he wished to voice. And this Dark Reign hijacking is killing it. (I recognize that it's possible that Matt Fraction wanted to recenter Tony Stark as less intelligence-enhanced, rebooting him, if you will, back to his original state. But I don't think it needs to take half to three quarters of a year to do that.)

  4. I was ecstatic to find out that DC was going to publish a Red Tornado miniseries, and reserved a copy before finding out that the plot was going to be the introduction of a set of Red androids, each dealing with one of the classic elements. It's a hackneyed idea in concept, and its execution doesn't make it any less hackneyed (why does everything always have to relate to the four elements?). And if you're going to have all the androids named after natural disasters, having the water one be named Red Torpedo is a bit off-pattern, though I can see DC wanting to maintain the character name and I guess Red Tidal Wave would have some nasty connotations. On the plus side, however, Kevin VanHook has a fairly good grasp of Reddy and the art by Luis and Mayer is fairly sharp. I don't want to leave my shop with extra copies of the miniseries I ordered so I'll remain on board through the end, but I hope this relatively unknown creative team can raise the book above its silly concept.

  5. It's little errors like the one in the Superwoman origin backup in the Supergirl Annual that drive me nuts, because they're so easily avoidable. According to the story, Lucy Lane skipped college, was a flight attendant, then joined the Army, where she quickly rose to the rank of major. Yeah, no. No college, no commission. Not unless you're a mustang, and she's far, far too young to be one of those. There are some rules that even a general can't break and get away with it.

Posted by JL Franke at September 9, 2009 11:22 PM

Comments
#1 ::: Greg Morrow ::: September 10, 2009 6:13 AM ::: link

The classical four elements now irritate me whenever an author brings them in. Show a little creativity. If you must make a classical allusion, try something that doesn't get used as often. Display a little erudition.

(Also, while I won't dismiss "torpedo" out of hand, I'm going to need justification why an element-themed grouping extrapolated from "tornado" didn't go with "tsunami".)

#2 ::: Jeff R. ::: September 10, 2009 12:09 PM ::: link

Greg: Didn't you yourself do a post on how important it is for DC characters to end their names with "-o"? Tornado, Inferno, Volcano...can't go 'Tsuami' from there, can you?

#3 ::: Dan Coyle ::: September 10, 2009 12:09 PM ::: link

The four elements? Christ, hasn't Widdle Brad wrecked the character ENOUGH, now VanHook's got to come in and retcon shit like this to make it "Deeper"?

#4 ::: Greg Morrow ::: September 10, 2009 1:07 PM ::: link

Jeff, that's just like you to throw consistency up in my face, like you're some sort of reality-supporting leftist socialist progressive or something.

Tornado, Torpedo, Inferno, and Volcano do have a pleasing three-syllable, seven-phoneme*, second-syllable stress, terminal -o structure, don't they. Almost worth the elemental shoehorning.

*I'm assuming a rhotic pronunciation and ignoring diphthonged production of long-a (i.e. /eI/) as a phonetic realization. Sure, you could say "seven-letter", but the relationship of orthography to speech is not simple and you know it.

#5 ::: Jonathan L. Miller ::: September 10, 2009 2:12 PM ::: link

Dan, didn't Reddy get stuck with all the "actually an Air Elemental" stuff back in the '80s? I don't particularly care for it, but place the blame for the idea where it's due with...whoever the hell came up with it back then. ;-)

(Also, the multiple Red andriods was a Grant Morrison thing in 52, wasn't it?)

#6 ::: JL Franke ::: September 10, 2009 5:25 PM ::: link

Jonathan, that would be Gerry Conway who made Reddy the Tornado Champion trapped in an android's body back in 1981. Cary Bates and Greg Weisman were the ones who turned him into a pure elemental in the pages of Captain Atom in 1987.

#7 ::: David Van Domelen ::: September 10, 2009 9:18 PM ::: link

This was my first issue of not getting Iron Man since the relaunch.

#8 ::: Dan Coyle ::: September 11, 2009 12:47 PM ::: link

My trouble with Iron Man is he's still the guy who fucked over Spider-Man for no good reason other than JMS was mad at him.

Post a comment









Remember personal info?