| |
| God’s own yodeller called home | Music |
News 8 Austin confirms that yodeller Don Walser died yesterday of complications from diabetes (which can mean lots of things).
I saw Don Walser once, and it wasn’t my cuppa tea but it was well done and everyone I’ve ever talked to who knew him respected him, which isn’t always the case in the music business. The News 8 article mentions something I didn’t know, which that he used to open for the Butthole Surfers. Given that he’s also listed as being a “western swing” performer who kept alive the music of Bob Wills, I think I’ll see what I think of his stuff now.
And I am personally looking for the third shoe to drop. Texas has had a bad September, between Don and Ann.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 08:19 AM
:. |
Email from Danny and Mary Lee: The Upper Kirby District has renovated the Levy Park to include the planting of new trees. As part of this renovation, Houston Intown Magazine and the Upper Kirby District will dedicate a tree in the memory of Tim McGlashen and his contribution to the Houston music scene. It is a small gesture to the memory of a great man. The event will be come as you wish Saturday, September 30 from 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. The park is behind the Upper Kirby District office, located at 3015 Richmond Avenue at Kirby Drive. If you’re a friend of Tim’s and in the neighborhood, stop by and see his tree.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 11:12 PM
:. |
| Jackin’ in the Free World | Music |
Another iPod side effect? According to this MacWorld article ( iPods killed the radio star), there’s a new trend in Commercial Radio. Vast Playlists, ala, people’s iPods. LA’s Arrow becomes Jack-FMThe Los Angeles station is one of eight FM stations across the U.S. bearing the Jack moniker, according to this Chicago Tribune article. In Chicago, for example, the station formerly known as WKQK has bumped its playlist up by approximately 1,000 songs. Its Web site features a MP3 player device and the new slogan �Now on shuffle.�
And just in case those allusions to the iPod seem too veiled, consider what Mike Stern, vice president of programming for Emmis Radio Chicago, told the Tribune when explaining the rationale behind the format change.�With an iPod in their hands, people are getting used to a huge variety.�
Kuff and Pete may have something worthwhile to listen to soon, if Houston joins KC, Baltimore, Jackson, Aspen, and Indy in this grand experiment…
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 08:40 PM
:. |
| Pea-Green with Envy… | Music |
Yeah, Pete went to The Judys reunion.
Yeah, I’m really jealous.
Yeah, if they release a CD or have a show that I can get to, I’ll go.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 09:05 PM
:. |
So my friend Jay was reminiscing about BlarneyFest, the Celtic Music festival that he thought up and drove in 1995 in Houston, back when it was a risky proposition. Props to him for that. He had some pictures of his band in grass skirts singing “King of the Cannibal Islands”, and it inspired me to rewrite a reminiscing song for him.
Boy the way Joe Linbeck plays,
Songs released on cassette tapes.
Guys in skirts, we had it made
Those were the days
Everyone remembers Those Were the Days by Adams and Strouse, which was the theme song to All in the Family, right?
It’s darker than you think. And there are some lyrics that were too offensive for Archie Bunker…
(More:
...)
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:21 PM
:. |
| Good Things Come in Threes | Music |
All sorts of good things have happened musically for my friends in the past year or so. The Flying Fish Sailors are picking up steam again and put out a fine new album. Paisley Close did a fantastic job with their first album and are clearly the best new thing to happen to the Houston Celtic music scene in the aughts. And Feo y Loco have a gig scheduled at Dan Electro’s Guitar Bar this Saturday.
It’ll be just like old times, except that we won’t be there, because we’ve moved. I encourage my Houston friends to go see them and then rag on me for missing it.
EDIT: Yes, that is the real poster from Dan Electro’s. No, I don’t know why. I’m guessing the artist has not actually met our “three fat white guys.”
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 09:02 PM
:. |
|
KLOL, Houston’s classic rock station (formerly Houston’s Album Oriented Rock station, is now Latino&Proud Mega101.
I blame James Watt.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:54 AM
:. |
| Review: Los Lobos - Ride This | Music |
I don’t really know the story behind Ride This! by Los Lobos, but I have theories. The album is a companion to The Ride, and it covers 7 songs by Tom Waits, Elvis Costello, Ruben Blades, and others. One track (Marie, Marie) is live, from 1999. The tracks are originally by artists who are either longtime partners with Los Lobos are by artists with whom they recorded songs on The Ride. My theory is that they put on the originals of these songs when they were producing the album as reference tracks and they decided they liked them so much that they recorded them and decided ‘hey, we’ve got something here…’ It’s probably not how it happened, but it could have…
(More:
...)
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:53 PM
:. |
|
Katie Melua’s Call off the Search is servicable. If you heard her singing while you and a date ate a romantic meal, you’d be perfectly satisfied. She has a good voice, a fine instinct for jazz infused pop vocals, and enough presence to be interesting. Interesting is necessary but not sufficient to carry the performance above “good” on the meter.
I could be acccused of damning her with faint praise, and it wouldn’t be too far off the mark. There’s very little that is wrong with this album and most of the pieces are right, but they never come together in a whole that is greater than the sum of the parts. It looks like an airplane, but it never takes off.
My only serious complaint, other than ‘it should do more for me’, has to do with the song choices. Whoever chose these seems to have been thinking ‘I’ve found the perfect song for Katie’s voice’, without noticing that the song isn’t perfect for Katie. The two songs that trip the ‘what where they thinking’ breaker are The Closest Thing To Crazy and My Aphrodisiac Is You
The Closest Thing To Crazy suffers from bringing up her youth. “Feeling twenty two, acting seventeen” and “How can you treat me like a child?” are unfortunate lyrics for a nineteen year-old singer who is clearly not much more than a child. It’s not just a matter of paying dues, it’s a matter of being credible when you’re singing about life and changes. It jarred me out of the story, which is the wrong way to get my attention
My Aphrodisiac Is You also seems to be unsuited to a nineteen year old singer. It could work for an older singer, but I tend to think “doesn’t need chemical stimulants to be horny” is the standard case for teens. The biographical material sent with the album makes a great deal of her youth, but it’s not the unalloyed advantage that they seem to think it is.
Aside from that it’s a “good” album.. It’s the kind of thing you’ll like if you like this kind of thing and I hear potential in her voice. It’s easy enough on the ears, but it doesn’t command attention. There’s no compelling factor musicially or lyrically that would make you annoyed at your tablemates at the bar for talking. That’s too bad.
Maybe the next one will be stronger. Maybe it won’t be such a safety play. I’d prefer that. This is good, but good isn’t good enough.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 06:52 AM
:. |
|
The Jersey City Irish Festival takes place on the doorstep of my office, but it won’t come around again until September. Maybe by then I’ll have some idea who the bands who play these things in NJ are…
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 06:48 PM
:. |
| I believe this to be a true statement | Music |
Polka is exactly like hip-hop, only Polish.
- It�s feared and maligned by people who aren�t part of the same disenfranchised culture.
- It�s been absorbed and tweaked by other cultures with similar disenfranchisement.
- It�s been co-opted and watered down by the corporations to sell products and control the youth population.
Polka is exactly like hip-hop, only Polish.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 05:26 PM
:. |
| Beer, beer, beer, beer, we love beer. | Music |
Rex “Wrecks” Bell, who played bass behind Townes Van Zandt and Lightnin’ Hopkins, runs the tiny but excellent Old Quarter Acoustic Cafe in Galveston (Rex ran the Old Quarter that Townes recorded in from 1966-1973, closing it some 17 years before I could drink). Now he wants to sell his own brand of beer, but Starbucks Coffee Corporation doesn’t like his brand name.
Now I may not be a typical consumer, but I could be a pretty typical patron of Rex’s. While he does have a stage at the Old Quarter and a PA, it’s easy to confuse it with a small drum riser. He likes the music and the two bands I’ve been with who went there had a good experience. Just not much for me to do there as the engineer. So mostly I got to sit and yak with Rex and listen to my friends play and try not to drink too much of what Rex poured. Hard to imagine a better gig for an engineer, really.
Beer! Oh, yes, Beer. Star Bock Beer. The name makes Starbucks Coffee Corporation’s caffeinated law corps deeply agitated. Someone might confuse Star Bock Beer with their brewed product. Could be, but really, Old Quarter patrons are more likely to confuse it with Lone Star Beer or Shiner Bock. This is partly because patrons are much more likely to be fans of inexpensive regional beers than expensive national coffee brands and partly because Rex named the brew by combining the names of his two most popular beers.
I dunno, I’m not buying real consumer confusion, but Starbucks has much bigger lawyers than The Old Quarter and these are not cases that the little guy frequently wins. However, Rex is a cantankerous old coot and may prevail on attitude alone.
If you’re in South East Texas and you want to hear good acoustic music, Rex’s Old Quarter is a good spot to go (on par with Anderson Fair and McGonigel’s Mucky Duck). Try the beer, whatever it ends up being named. And talk to a guy who has been a part of some of the best Texas blues ever made, too.
In any case, how can you take a company seriously that’s named after Dirk “Face” Benedict?
via Kuff
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 01:00 AM
:. |
| Gordian Knot Show, 10/3 | Music |
Gordian Knot, one of the really good parts of the vibrant Houston Celtic music scene of the 1990s, has put the band back together. They’ve got a gig this Friday at The Last Concert Cafe, one of the coolest music venues in Houston.
I am really psyched. I used to engineer for GK and I like them alot.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:35 AM
:. |
| Mor(e)on RIAA Due Process violations | Music |
Blogcritic ringleader Eric Olsen adds further details to my comments on the RIAA process, noting that Senator Sam Brownback (R.-Kan.) claims it calls into question the RIAA testimony about the controversial DMCA subpoenas. the problem is the extra-judicial nature of the subpoenas, which Brownback seems to recognize, combined with the willingness of the RIAA to use them like a hammer when a lighter touch might not have caused the reaction they’re getting.
Eric says:
Whether you feel the legal assault on file sharers is warranted or not, its foundation and efficacy now appear very shaky. How could such a mistake have been made?
I replied:
I can think of a number of ways this could happen, some accidental and some malicious. It’s easy to transpose a digit. It’s easy to get the time-stamp wrong on a request, or foul up the time-zone differences.
It’s not out of the question that someone at the ISP knew this wasn’t valid, but complied out of spite and the letter of the law.
And it’s also possible that Johnny Thugnextdoor is stealing Grandma Macuser’s internet connection because she didn’t put a password on her Airport WiFi base station.
What we’re seeing here is that the DMCA has some serious flaws and that the RIAA will exploit them.
It’s probably short-sighted on their part, since the lawsuits against 12 year old honor students and Mac-using grandmas will cause a backlash, but isn’t one of the long term industry problems the takeover by short-sighted beancounters who can’t look past the revenue forecasts?
The fine, obnoxious folks at TShirtHell.com just came out with a “Sharing is Caring” T-Shirt. RIAA backlash is coming to the masses.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:07 PM
:. |
| The Reliability of RIAA Subpoenas | Music |
The Register, the fun British tech news and curmudgeon site, has written about a quietly dropped RIAA lawsuit against a user accused of sharing 2000 songs.
The RIAA said Sarah Ward was sharing 2,000 songs through the KaZaA P2P network exposing her, at $150,000 per offense, to $300,000,000 in penalties. But not only had she never downloaded a song, but as a Macintosh user, she couldn’t even run the KaZaA software, which only runs on Windows.
While there are peer-to-peer options for Mac users, this certainly lowers the credibility of the entire RIAA approach. I’m imagining a lawyer whose case goes like this. “So, my client was selected by the same team of elite information gatherers who decided that a 66 year old woman was sharing 2000 songs via a Macintosh, which could not possibly have run the software you accused her of running. What makes you think you got this one right?”
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:44 AM
:. |
a perfectly cromulent blog makes a lovely cheap joke at the expense of the Rolling Stones over the porta-zone pictured at right. And yes, it’s better than the Metamucil joke one expects considering the Stones status as, shall we say, “Elder Statesmen” of Rock? The concert was supposed to attract close to half a million fans of the Rolling Stones and 15 other acts.
I, however, saw the vast array of colored outbuildings and wondered if something like this might be the final layout for the porta-potties…
Yeah, it would have been funnier before the concert. But, hey, art takes time and so did this.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 03:01 PM
:. |
So the recording project is pretty much done. Liz came over and we burned 24 CDs. I keep listening to the one I made for me and I keep wanting to tweak it.
I want to go into School House Rock and re-normalize each section of the medley. I want to get the voices up on the speaking parts without getting the electrical hum. I want to fix the gap in Helplessly Hoping. I want the effen’ tape not to have that clipping on it.
(More:
...)
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:37 AM
:. |
| Further evidence of the Onionification of Real Life | Music |
According to a BBC journalist in Baghdad, RIAA Lobbyist Hilary B. Rosen is rewriting the intellectual property laws for the new government of Iraq.
Why do I bother trying to write satire when it’s indistinguishable from actual events? Tom Lehrer retired from performing music because “Political satire became obsolete when Kissinger was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize.” I know how he felt.
(via Democracy Now site not updated with 4/13 program info yet…)
Cross posted to BlogCritics
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:24 AM
:. |
| A not-particularly zen koan | Music |
So, we were sitting in our local bar (ask Ginger sometime about having a local bar) and the waitress sets down a bowl of popcorn at another table. Sadly, she is in a hurry and accidentally places the paper napkin part of the bowl of popcorn in the candle with the expected results. Thinking quickly, she snatches the bowl back and carries it, like an olympic torchbearer, to the bar where it can be extinguished and replaced. This would have been a particularly dull story except that when she was almost back to the bar an errant bit of flaming napkin fell on Angelo’s back. Luckily we were seated at the very back row of tables next to the bar. A patron standing at the bar stepped over and deftly brushed the flaming debris from Ang’s back before it caught his hair or shirt on fire.
“What just happened?” Ang asked.
“The waitress set you on fire,” Liz said.
“You should buy that woman a drink for extinguishing you,” I said.
And he did.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 11:11 PM
:. |
| Microsoft on the futility of DRM | Music |
The Register reports today on a MS whitepaper delivered at the ATM DRM conference on the futility of content protection and the future of Content Distribution.
It’s a good read, especially if you think the RIAA has caused a lot of their own problems by not understanding what their consumers want.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:44 AM
:. |
| The Book business: indicator of the future of the music business? | Music |
Michael Wolff of New York Metro compares the future of the music industry to the current publishing industry.
This interesting take on the future of the industry takes a different look at the question of the future of music. The article isn’t about the collapse of the music industry paradigm, it’s about what happens when a star-based paradigm collapses, and it finds a parallel in the book publishing industry. It takes it as a given that the collapse is happening. I’ve discussed Virginia Postrel’s take on the economics of book print-runs as applied to the recording industry, but didn’t take the parallels as far as Wolff. And that’s just his jumping-off point.
If you’re providing free entertainment, which is obviously what the music business is doing, then you have to figure out some way to sell advertising to the people who are paying attention to your free music. But nobody seems to have any idea how that might be done. Or you can provide stuff that’s free, and use the free stuff to promote something else of more value thatpeople, you hope, will buy — now called the “legitimate alternative.” (Putting video on the CD is one of those ideas — though, of course, you can file-share video too.) Or sell the CD at a level that makes it cheap enough to compete with free (free, after all, has its own costs for the consumer).
It’s a spreadsheet solution. There will continue to be a market for selling music, however diminished — but it will have to be cheaper music. Margins will shrink even more. Accordingly, costs will have to shrink. Spending a few million to launch an act will shortly be a thing of the past. (The formal catalyst of the beginning of the end of big development costs may be the Wall Street Journal’s story a few months ago that precisely accounted for the $2.2 million launch costs of a singer named Carly Hennessy, who went onto sell 378 CDs.) A&R guys making half a million are also history (in the future, they’ll start at $40,000 and max out at $150,000). And no more parties.
Amongst the other implications is that the key to controlling the future of the industry is controlling the filtering mechanisms people use to find music.
Worth a read, including the disturbing idea that the success of the music industry is an unsustainable bubble built on the baby boom and effectively over.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:17 PM
:. |
| Is this how Natalie Cole got her idea? | Music |
The Singing Dictionary (Mirror) is a labor of love. Love is not necessarily pretty, but it’s interesting.
I’ll let them describe it…
Main Entry: dic�tio�nar�a�o�ke
Pronunciation: ‘dik-sh&-“ner-A-O-ke
Definition: Audio clips from online dictionaries sing the hits of yesterday and today. The fun of karaoke meets the word power of the dictionary.
Certainly few people will want all 100 songs they have posted, but it’s way fun. And there is a certain opportunity for, um, editorializing in the vocal tracks. :)
NP: Dictionaraoke-“Waterloo”
via SJ Games Daily Illuminator
UPDATE: Ok, I wasn’t going to comment on the variety, which is huge, but there are some interesting notes. Artists: Janis Joplin, Culturecide, Madonna, Johnny Cash, Depeche Mode, Moxy Fr�vous, Irving Berlin, Dr. Dre. Elvis, NiN, Tom Jones, Ohio Express, Britney, Boys Don’t Cry. Lots more.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:21 AM
:. |
| He who would cross this blog of fate… | Music |
Eric Olsen of Tres Producers is kicking off his blogcritics.com project with a bang! He has arranged for Cary Sherman, President of the RIAA to answer questions submitted by reviewers. Since I almost didn’t participate in the project because I consider the RIAA to be anti-technology and anti-artist, I consider this a great opportunity to find out some of the things that have been bugging me about RIAA positions. All this is in addition to the regular reviews of CDs and Books that blogcritics.com will host. I’m not sure if they really want me, however, because I probably won’t review anything by a major label.
This is the list of questions I submitted. Answers and responses will follow as available.
First, I want to thank Mr. Sherman for taking the time to respond to our comments. As a copyright holder on all my own written works and as a sometime recording engineer, and as a computer software professional, I am a firm supporter of intellectual property protection. However I have noticed an increasing gap between statements and positions and legislation sponsored by the RIAA and my interests as a technology and entertainment consumer. I hope Mr. Sherman’s participation can both sensitize him and the RIAA to concerns of consumers like me and clarify some of the unfortunate statements made by RIAA spokespeople that have so alienated consumers in the past few years.
- As a consumer, I find myself increasingly leery of RIAA member products which might appear to be CDs, but which use an intentionally corrupted format that can damage my Macintosh computer. This risk is an increasing consideration in my decision to buy or pass on a major label CD and I have begun to avoid major label products to protect my computer, which is, after all, much more important to me than any one CD. What is the RIAA position on members who intentionally release products in corrupted formats?
- It seems to be an article of faith in the RIAA and major label circles that sales are off due to Internet piracy. Critics counter that you are not offering products that consumers want, or not offering them in the way they want, or charging too much, or that you are ignoring the business cycle, consumer confidence, competition from other markets, or that your prospective customers are being turned off because you tell them that you assume they’re thieves. What makes you sure that the cause of your misfortunes is the illegal activities of others?
- The Canadian Private Copying Collective (an industry group in Canada) has proposed a $21 (Canadian) per Gigabyte Blank Media Levy on hard drive based MP3 players, which would add approximately $420cn to the cost of a (currently $800cn) 20 GB Apple iPod. The RIAA supports similar Blank Media Levies in the United States. Does the RIAA have a position on the Canadian Blank Media Levy and would the RIAA support a 50% increase in the cost of an MP3 player as part of a similar levy in the US?
- The technical parallel the RIAA tries to make between licensing software and licensing music is an interesting one. As a software developer, I am expected to provide my customers with replacement media if they damage or lose their originals, providing they can prove they did purchase the license (at a reasonable cost, since what they have purchased is just a license, after all). I have several damaged or lost CDs. Do RIAA member labels intend to offer similar replacement media?
- Similarly, software licenses almost universally allow for the creation of a backup copy in case something happens to my original. Does the RIAA acknowledge my right to create a backup?
- If the RIAA license stops allowing the two rights listed above, do members labels plan to lower the cost of the license (and thus the CDs) to reflect the lessened value in the license?
- RIAA supports proposals on Digital Rights Management requirements for software operating systems. The vision of computer/OS level control of DRM seems to willfully ignore the Open Source software model. It would either make it illegal to use open source OSes, or provide them with a competitive advantage over DRM-enabled OS. How does the RIAA propose that developers resolve the DRM proposal’s incompatibility with truly open software?
- RIAA has supported Howard Berman’s proposed legislation allowing copyright owners to search for and disable access to networks that are illegally distributing or sharing their works without the risk of arrest on charges of illegal hacking. As a copyright owner of many written works, would this mean the RIAA would support my hacking into any system that I believed might contain an illegal copy of my copyrighted works? Could I use use otherwise illegal means to remove sites that I believed hosted my works on the Internet? Is the harm done by these sites more important than all existing anti-hacking laws?
- Hillary Rosen has criticized Gateway for providing “misleading” information in order to sell more CD burners. How does Gateway’s expression of support for digitalconsumer.org and opposition to DRM on philosophical grounds constitute “misleading” information? Does the RIAA have an official position on Gateway’s statement that I have the right to copy CDs I own to my computer and my MP3 player?
- Hillary Rosen has previously stated (in response to Cannon/Boucher) that “The bill substitutes government regulation for the marketplace. This is not only wrong, it is also inconsistent with the strongly held views of experts and the private sector that government regulation of the Internet would be a disastrous mistake. ” Has the RIAA position on regulating the Internet changed?
- In 1983, Jack Valenti of the MPAA said “I say to you that the VCR is to the American film producer and the American public as the Boston strangler is to the woman home alone.” Why should anyone believe media industry associations this time?
- What is the RIAA position on the lawsuit alleging that Sam Moore and many other artists were not provided contractually mandated pension and health benefits for over 30 years?
- How does the RIAA respond to allegations on foxnews and elsewhere that their member labels must be using deceptive accounting practices when they claim that records that sell 2 million copies have not ever broken even or turned a profit?
- How does the RIAA respond to the suggestion that by suppressing Internet Radio and fair use by computer consumers they are not protecting the rights of artists but are interested in preserving their oligopoly on music distribution from the technologies that have made it obsolete?
Frankly, I don’t think the RIAA can answer these questions honestly without revealing their inner weasels. I’ll update when I hear more…
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 11:58 PM
:. |
| Review: The Buddahcrush (2001) 10 songs, 53 minutes | Music |
Rock and Roll needs more saxophones. There’s a dimension missing from the Lead Guitar/Rhythm Guitar/Bass Guitar/Drum foursome that no combination of pedals can really imitate. A sax is expressive and versatile, at turns Jazzy or Bluesy. It’s almost an emotional layer.
For the Buddhacrush, it’s a lynchpin of a protean sound that never settles into a single genre. This is hardly surprising, since the bandmembers came together from wildly different musical backgrounds. Rock/Blues/Jazz/Reggae/Celtic/Pop/Soul—you name it, they’ve probably done a bit of it.
The great thing is that the sax doesn’t have to carry that role alone. The saxophone doesn’t get overused because the fiddler is playing off his riffs. Not only do they have the depth to provide a wide variety of configurations, the members of the Buddhacrush have the experience to blend it all into an album of songs that are consistently musically interesting. And it’s fun. You listen to the music and you’re sure that people get up and dance at their shows. “Twice As Good” makes my butt move in my chair, which can be dangerous on the freeways. On other songs, they coax the sax/fiddle combination into a Morrocan flavored languid lushness.
But what I really like on the Buddhacrush is the songwriting. Some songwriting is storytelling and some is photography. Tim McGlashen’s songwriting is painting in oils. Brushstrokes broad or narrow capture the essential image, imply the motion, reinforce the musical feeling. It’s not a snapshot; it’s more precise. It’s deliberate choices about what it will take to capture something.
The songs are multi-layered. “Like Shakespeare Waiting to Happen” is told by a man who is in love with a woman who doesn’t see him and the tragedy for both of them of the missed opportunity. Like Hamlet’s The Murder of Gonzago, the key is how the players react to the story within the story. It hints and suggests, but the song won’t tell you. You get to figure it out yourself.
I like that. I like lyrics that expect me to think, to know what a reference to Ophelia might imply. I like songs that assume that I’ll either know who Django Reinhardt was or I’ll get it from context (or look him up on the web). I enjoy a songwriter who isn’t willing to cede The Grapes of Wrath to Bruce Springsteen.
This is an album I put in the MP3 player rotation. I like hybrids; I think they have inherent vigor. There is something naturally fresh, exciting, and interesting in putting pieces together and making them work. The Buddhacrush CD sends back 10 paintings from a very interesting place that they seem to be creating themselves.
Listen on their web site, and buy online from CDStreet, CDBaby, or Amazon.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 01:56 AM
:. |
The Houston Press’s annual music awards were published in this week’s edition of our weekly altTM newsrag. It’s supposed to be better: more care, more local reporting, a better feel for the music scene.
Except when it isn’t.
The Press started, some six or seven years ago, a Best Celtic Music category in their annual doo-dah contest. This was theoretically better than the “Best World Music” or “Best Ethnic Music”, which compared Celtic to African drummers or Eastern European gypsy music.
Now, there’s nothing wrong with either of those competitors, but you’ll never determine one is ‘better’ than the other, because they really don’t have an overlapping audience. At best you’ll find out which band has more readers of the Press. That might be the idea, of course, but it’s supposed to determine ‘best’, so some rational comparison would be useful.
Eventually, Ceili’s Muse won, some 18 months after the band officially broke up.
This year, The Flying Fish Sailors won. They beat out Jiggernaut. Ceili’s Muse was nominated (as “Cecil’s Muse”), but Clandestine and The Rogues were not.
That’s absurd. They still (after 5 or more years running the category) don’t know or care who plays Celtic music in Houston. Fine, maybe (as Maggie Drennon of Ceili’s Muse used to say) “Celtic musicians are the nerds of the music Industry.” Nerds don’t get respect, apparently, from the powers that be at the Alt paper. I’m really glad for my friends in the FFS, but damn, I wish it had been a better race, so they could have had a more meaningful win.
In my world, the contestants would have been:- Clandestine
Powerful, beautiful songwriting backed by killer bagpipes and cool vocal harmonies - The Flying Fish Sailors
This revitalized local group smoothly moves from sea songs to love songs to songs of rednecks who abduct aliens. Don’t ask me, just go see them. - Jiggernaut
The up and comer in the lot, with survivors from several favorites melding together into a folk/celt/rock-pop fusion thing that delivers solid fun. - The Rogues
Houston’s unabashed Bad Boys with Bagpipes, the Rogues are fast, furious and fun.
If that had been the line up, I’d’ve been very satisfied. As an engineer, I’ve worked shows with 3/4ths of them and I like and respect them all and I attend shows by all of them. It would have been a horse-race between three old favorites and an exciting newcomer. There isn’t a one of those bands whom I’d’ve been sorry to see win. But that wasn’t the line up, because they didn’t ask me. They didn’t even ask Wolf Loescher, who was in Ceili’s Muse and is in Jiggernaut. I’ve no idea where they got their list, but it wasn’t written by anyone who’s paid any attention since the turn of the century.
Not knowing the major players in the field? And listing a defunct one instead? I wanted to vote for Mel Carnahan.
Instead, I wrote The Press a letter. We’ll see what (if anything) they do with it…
Does News Hostage print stories about clumsy reporting errors in the Press?
While I understand your desire to expand to new genres of music, I would suggest that before you do so, you should make sure you can adequately handle the categories you’ve got.
I found your nominations in the Celtic music category bizarre and sloppy. Your first listed nominee was “Cecil’s Muse”, which you later corrected to “Ceili’s Muse”, a band that last performed in 1997. You neglected to nominate “Clandestine”, who have been a mainstay of the Houston Celtic music scene for years, and whose last studio album was produced by Gerry O’Beirne. Certainly they deserved a nod before a band that hasn’t been performing for five years.
I am happy for my friends in the FFS that they have won;they are talented, versatile, and interesting. Their win would have been more meaningful if they had been competing against their peers.
[email address not for publication, please]
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 03:46 PM
:. |
| The root of all evil… | Music |
The Register prints a reply from a reader of their excellent coverage of the RIAA/MPAA rights-grab lobby and their time-shared Senators. Harley Aulance certainly has the list of greivances against the MPAA and RIAA correctly enumerated.
While I’d vote for this legislation, what I’d really like is not permission to hack them back, but rather massive and punative damages against the lobbyists in any case where this bad legislation is enacted. Not to exceed 10,000 times the amount contributed to legislators, perhaps. Oh, and impeach the recipients of these brib gifts.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 05:20 PM
:. |
| Why I don’t want the major labels to send me free CDs… | Music |
Eric Olsen proposes a program of Free CDs for Bloggers in exchange for reviews of them.
I agonized. Ginger reviews every concert we attend and talks about music frequently. I regularly write about Music, Technology, and the Law. We’re both big fans of live local music.
But…
Aside from questions about the intentionally non-commercial nature of my site, aside from not wanting to commit to a certain number of reviews for the privilege, aside from not wanting to get the hit counts out of the logs to show them that I am a good prospect…
The showstopper was that it would be promoting major labels, who are fighting against the future of the industry and hurting consumers to do so.
I was going to write a long essay on why I wasn’t going to participate, but Josh Kortbein beat me to it. So I replied to Eric. I asked him if there was a way to modify the concept to support indy/unsigned acts only. We’ll see what comes of it.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:54 AM
:. |
|
When Pigs Fly is a CD that exposes the bizarre side of my so-called musical taste. The album is a collection of unusual covers. If you’re willing to listen to what The Fixx does with These Boots Are Made For Walkin’ and Herman’s Hermits’ version of White Wedding.
If you don’t have mental whiplash yet, check out the Leslie Gore take on Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap or the Jackie Chan/Ani DiFranco duet.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:33 AM
:. |
|
Gateway.com: Digital Music Zone
The mail order PC manufacturer post a singing cow who dislikes the CBTDPA and links to the grass roots digital consumer web site.
Thanks, Gateway. I still don’t want your computers, but I think you’ve got panache.
via /., wired, etc…
Oh, hey. Check out the rap/rock remix of Gordon Lightfoot’s Sundown by Elwood. Good stuff. I will follow Gateway’s advice and download it from their website and copy it to my MP3 player.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:12 AM
:. |
| Political Activism in the Naughts… | Politics |
Electronic communication being what it is, I found and bothered all three of the contenders to replace outgoing national and state embarrassment Phil Gramm. I’m cautiously optimistic, because
- It can’t get worse that Gramm
- Cornyn has a better track record than most
- Ron Kirk also looks reasonable.
Maybe this time next year, Kay Bailey will be the most whacked Texas Senator.
Oh, and I asked the Cornyn campaign about S.2048, the “Screw consumers and treat them all like criminals to protect Disney’s failing business model for selling music Act” (spelled “Consumer Broadband and Digital Television Promotion Act” in Washington and at the bank…). I am tentatively pleased with their reply:
Michael - based on an analysis of the bill, I don’t think John Cornyn would support the measure. While the desire to protect intellectual property is important, this bill could strangle innovation and not improve the protection of intellectual property as intended.
Matt Winslow
John Cornyn for Senate
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 09:50 PM
:. |
| Watching Lawyers Fight… | Music |
Salon discusses Web Radio and the DCMA requirements that will by paperwork and costs, eliminate small-scale, self published sites.
It’s not the CBDTPA, but it is more sickitude from the RIAA.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:13 PM
:. |
| At least he isn’t promoting this legislature to ‘protect the children’… | Music |
Richard Forno of Inforwarrior.com writes about CDBTPA in The Register and largely gets it right. I think some of his examples of applicable devices are exaggerated, but he understands the story.
I’ve been writing to the candidates for Phil Gramm’s senate seat and seeing what position they have on it. The Cornyn people are aware of it and cautious, but don’t have a position yet. More detailed reports to follow.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 07:40 PM
:. |
| Consumer Rights for the Digital Consumer | Music |
DigitalConsumer.org Home Page discusses current and proposed copyright holder’s infringement on consumer’s digital rights, especially as embodied in enacted or proposed US law. It’s great background info to the issue that’s been raised here and elsewhere on the web.
Choice destinations at their website:
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:59 PM
:. |
| Canada shows us what the SSSCA could look like in practice… | Music |
Information on the Blank Media Levy
Canada shows us what Fritz Hollings (D-Disney) has been fighting to provide as a benefit for his handlers. Of particular note is the slope of the curve from what were probably considered small costs that wouldn’t burden anyone and the rest of the camel which is on it’s way into the tent.
The proposed blank media levy of $21 (canadian) per GB of storage on a personal MP3 player would raise the cost of an iPod from $599 canadian to $704 canadian. If the price remains the same and the storage space doubles twice (a conservative estimate, actually…), the iPod of 2004 might cost $1019 instead of $599.
Of course, since the law states the the media must never have had a recording on it, a refurbished iPod could still be $599.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 09:48 PM
:. |
| More Anti-SSSCA articles… | Music |
Steven Levy of Newsweek writes that the RIAA and MPAA think that The Customer Is Always Wrong and Wired thinks the House of Representatives won’t play along with Hollings (via Instapundit).
Wired suggests that this is because of politics: Apparently Senator Fritz is against Tauzin-Dingell. I can’t say I’ll be sorry if the TelcoRepresentatives block the MediaSenator’s pet bill for retaliatory purposes.
The Texas Legislature convenes only in odd numbered years and can only convene for a maximum of 140 days. The US Congress can do damage at much more lesuirely pace.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:48 PM
:. |
| Why Didn’t Senator Hollings Have Steve Jobs Appear? | Music |
I think it was because Jobs is in the best position to understand the situation and he disagrees with Holling’s leash-holders. Jobs is CEO of Apple Computer, maker of Operating Systems, Computers and digital devices and CEO of Pixar, maker of copyrighted video and audio content.
He’s the architect of Apple’s Digital Hub Strategy and Apple took home a technical Grammy for their “outstanding technical contributions to the music industry and recording field.”
It would be difficult to find a more relevant witness.
According to the Wall Street Journal:“If you legally acquire music, you need to have the right to manage it on all other devices that you own,” said Jobs. So I guess he’s not really relevant to Holling’s SSSCA hearings, because they already had a victim from the computer industry.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 04:09 PM
:. |
| Anyone find a blog that’s sympathetic to the RIAA yet? | Music |
I don’t think there is one, since Fritz Hollings doesn’t have a blog.
Happy Fun Pundit weighs in on the music industry and the DRM issue. He’s nailed the problem with the RIAA’s deep denial of the problem with their content, and he’s got the same solution for the retail problem that I discussed in January.
Everyone I know who is right always agrees with me.— Rev. Lady Mal, in Principia Discordia
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 08:44 PM
:. |
| Intellectual Property and Creative Control | Music |
Ginger looks at Confessions of a Working Woman and finds this arresting quote:If you make something, you should have complete control over that thing, whether it’s art, music or prose.
Heady stuff. It’s certainly not the way that Intellectual Property law works, not in every case. And we don’t even want to go near what the patent laws says, because they don’t just bend this principle, they break it hard.
You certainly don’t have this kind of creative control as a songwriter. If you have written and recorded a song, you cannot stop me from recording your song. You cannot stop me from changing your words. You cannot require me to tell you in advance (you may not find out until you get a check. If you don’t own your own rights, you may not find out ever.) You will get a royalty, but it’s not that much. If you pick a fight with me in a bar in Scandinavia because I took your song, you’ll get a reputation as an ass, even if we were both drunk at the time.
There is one fascinating clause that states that the author has the right to prevent any release of a song but only if no one has released it yet. There are songs that will never be released, because the artist won’t release them in order to prevent someone else from releasing a cover.
The music industry manages to live without complete control by the songwriters over their product. This is certainly because the rules about it were written to favor the corporations rather than the creative artists, but that is a different rant.
Philosophically, I’m with Ginger (surprise!). Copyright is a system to prevent economic harm to creative artists and those to whom they sell their products. The moral scope of it is limited to not causing economic harm to the creator by not stealing.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 01:34 AM
:. |
| Essential Reading if you’re interested in music: A History of Record Production to 1950 | Music |
Eric Olsen of Tres Producers traces the history of the recording industry with a look at the technological and musical revolutions that brought us to the era that gave us our current business model.
Highlights include:
- What they called ‘Producers’ before that was the word for it. (The Linguist in me smiles…)
- How Edison’s business dictation machine unintentionally created an industry
- Format Wars, part one: Edison Cylinders vs. 78s
- How technological innovation during WWI led to the “electric age” of microphones and amplifiers. (Shades of the RAND corporation and the Internet!)
- How Billie Holiday broke the (in-studio) color barrier by recording with Benny Goodman
- Format Wars, part two: 45s and LPs
- How technological innovation during WWII led to the “magnetic age” of recording tape. (Shades of the RAND corporation and the Internet, again!)
- The Creation of Nashville as a music center
Plus stories about the seminal artists who created the foundations of modern music and many of the producers who made it happen. If you know the artists’ names, thank the producers.
Great stuff, thanks, Eric.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 12:38 AM
:. |
| What is Philips Up To? | Music |
According to The Register, Philips is considering withholding permission to use the official CD Logo on CDs that are copy protected if they won’t play in DVD players, Macs, and CD burners. They almost have to do this, if they’ve certified that those devices (which Philips also produces, coincidentally) will play any Red Book compliant disc. So if they will play any Red Book disc and they won’t play More of The Fast and The Furious, then it can’t be a Red Book compliant disc. Simple logic. It’ll be interesting to see how this is resolved.
In other exciting CD news, the same Register story tells of Philips exciting take on the DMCA. They will produce CD burners which ignore the copy protection, because it’s not really copy protection. It’s an anti-playback scheme, not an anti-copy scheme. They’re right, but only because it’s of no use to copy something if it can’t be played back. Seems like the RIAA didn’t get everyone on the bus before they left the station…
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 11:39 AM
:. |
| Singing from the Same Hymnal | Music |
Dwight Silverman’s Computing column in today’s Houston Chronicle is entitled Music industry behind the digital beat. I don’t always agree with Dwight, but on this issue he’s never missed a note. He understands and has been talking for years about the issues I raised in my music industry rant Paradigm Shift.
Highlights from Dwight on this topic:
- Licensing Music is like Licensing Software (Real Audio)—Note, I think Dwight should’ve included songwriters in the underpaid artist side of the equation; typically they get 6-10 cents per CD per song for their creative endeavors.
- Here’s the point that the music industry just can’t seem to comprehend: Consumers will not flock to any pay service that constrains what they do with the music they download.
- Consumers as well as artists who are concerned about the music labels’ stranglehold on rights have started complaining about the situation to lawmakers.
- While the music industry is a powerful lobby, a horde of angry voters is even more compelling in an election year.
Dwight had a draft model for a replacement paradigm defined more than a year and a half ago, in his column Helping Napster Survive. He saw the iceberg long before the RIAA did. Add him to the list of people who will be able to say I told you so when the rest of the world discovers there has been a revolution.
While I don’t think Rep. Conyers was referring to me, it’s nice to know that the RIAA is getting the message, even if I suspect that they aren’t listening.The Internet says to the [music recording and publishing] industry that you folks are yesterday’s news, you’re following outdated models, your business strategies don’t work anymore, and your profit motive is showing rather vulgarly.—John Conyers, D-Mich (via Silverman)
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 10:14 AM
:. |
| One Day Ahead of The Times | Music |
I read two interesting articles related to my Paradigm Shift entry in the New York Times today (registration required). One was by influential Blogger Virginia Postrel and the other was by the NY Times Pop and Jazz music critics.
Postrel is discussing the marginal and opportunity costs in the book publishing industry. Parallel concerns exist in the music industry, although changes in the variables produce different decisions.“The economic way of thinking,” as the late Paul Heyne titled his popular introductory textbook, includes the analytical tools that economists take for granted among themselves and try to teach their students. Knowing these basic concepts could keep a lot of people from making economic mistakes. Postrel wants book publishers to account for additional copies of books using marginal production costs without including static expenses that will be incurred whether the (N+1)th book is produced or not. The same errors in economic calculations that cause books to be underrun initially also cause CDs to be underrun initially. It’s a model that point-of-sale production eliminates. The costs of production of a CD on-demand model are quite different from a warehouse/wholesale/retail model. It’s a shame the technology to produce and distribute text in a new paradigm (such as a blog) doesn’t scale easily to a book’s worth of data.
The music critics are already aware of the production model changes and the dramatically lower cost of entry. This is a boon for them because their value in determining what is and isn’t worthwhile is much greater when there is more content. They introduce their
Best of the Obscure Among 2001’s Albums column with an acknowlegement that there is no way to evaluate the entirety of the music released in 2001. Emphasis mine.Now that every computer and every apartment is a potential recording studio and every musician could be a do-it-yourself independent label, more than 20,000 albums are released each year, more than any single fan, radio station or critic could possibly assess fully. That means that richly deserving music can go unnoticed, drowned out by better-promoted albums or rendered inaccessible because it eludes the easy categorization that could make it marketable. The New York Times critics can provide you with the filtering you need to find the worthwhile products in the data overload that lowered costs of entry provide, despite the misdirection of marketing. If they become the Oprah-like arbiters of musical content, they will be very powerful indeed.
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 07:55 PM
:. |
Unqualified Offerings says that Information Wants To Be $10, discussing the price cuts in label-produced CDs and concluding thatThe market has found a great deal of fat around the waistlines of record company weasels and is squeezing it out. I can’t agree. Not because the weasels are not corpulent nor because the facts are incorrect, but because the analysis doesn’t go far enough. I’m not a musician, but I’ve worked as a live, live recording, and studio engineer and have some decided opinions about the future of the industry.
I’ll start with the sweeping generalizations. The music recording industry is essentially a 20th-century phenomenon which will not survive as we know it because it is no longer the most efficient production and distribution model for most musical content. Because it has generated a great deal of income, the industry won’t just sit and quietly obsolesce, but will fight its increasing irrelevance with money and friendly legislation. Such is the nature of endangered industry. I won’t predict when, because I’ve never been that good of a chronoprognosticator.
The value of the industry to creative musicians, support staff, and consumers used to be quite clear. Labels provided the dedicated equipment, support staff, talent management, manufacturing, promotion, and distribution assets to connect the dots between the talent, the product, and the consumers. Sound familiar? It was the Hollywood studio system model in it’s day[1].
Like the Hollywood system, it was designed to produce creative output requiring intensive capital while minimizing risk to investors and producing a steady and predictable profit. Given the costs of production facilities and distribution costs and risks, it was the best deal available to the artists. And it made a lot of money.
That was then.
The past 20 years have seen a dramatic drop in the costs of production, with a half-million dollar studio producing products that are not noticeably different[2] from the products of an $80,000 digital professional studio and most recently not being much different[2] from a sub-$10,000 home studio. The gating factor is no longer the technology and is increasingly moving from cost to technical know-how.
With a lower cost of entry, a larger talent pool is gaining that know-how. Bands that used to rocket in and out of the studio in three days because of costs can spend the time they want with equipment they can afford. A computer-based home studio can be had for around the cost of producing a CD (at most two) in a big studio. These days, it has a CD burner for making the master, and if you cut corners on pro mastering[3], you can make a production ready CD in the comfort of your home studio.
There are trade offs: you save money by taking more time and having the ability to afford to make mistakes. If you don’t have a really talented mastering engineer in an expensive facility, you may not be happy with the results.
There was increasing strain on the production side of the equation for years, but it only went so far. Independent bands and artists cut CDs with “semi-pro” gear and had increasingly professional results, but that didn’t put your CD on the shelf at Sam Goody.
It’s a good thing this option developed, because the RIAA kept chipping away at the benefits to the artists. Some became superstars and got rich, but a lot more didn’t. Ever wonder why we have so many artist produced albums and what started the shift to the performer/songwriter model? If you guessed anything except economic pressure, you’re wrong. Bands that require producers and songwriters have to pay them, or else have them paid for by the studios. It’s much more cost effective to have the production costs be paid by the artists and it keeps payroll low. There’s nothing wrong with singing songs other people wrote, except that the labels don’t like it[4].
Fast forward (remember “fast forward”? It was what we did with old serial access data storage media like cassettes[5] or 8-tracks…) to the Napster/Gnutella era. Music can be stored in small files that are close enough to the artist’s original version that they can replace CDs and we start thinking about digital libraries of music—data CDs that hold 5 times the number of MP3s as red book CDs hold songs, DVD-Rs that hold hundreds. Music becomes data stored on cheap media and downloadable and perfectly transferable without loss of quality.
That’s the second leg of the RIAA model unravelling. It’s no longer necessary to have a huge production plant, warehouse and distribution model to produce CDs. MP3.com has an online CD model that earns the artist $3 and the web site $7 from any $9.99 CD sold. For the artist, this is 4-6 times the amount made by a RIAA CD and for MP3.com, this is better than the $5 a bricks-and-mortar store would have grossed, without the issues of location or inventory. Their inventory is a stack of blank CDs. They don’t go bad or have to be remaindered. Compare that to the RIAA model Unqualified Offerings discusses. This is a disaster for the labels, who go from making serious money to being cut out of the loop completely. No wonder they are cranky.
An MP3.com store at the mall would only need to be a bunch of terminals, a server, a label printer, a few burners and blank discs and one owner-operator. Nothing would ever be out of print. Kinkos could do this as a self-serve operation. Anyone could do this. Music production stops being about industrial, scalable production and distribution models for a physical good and starts being about post-industrial data distribution. We lose the cost of entry and the barriers to alternatives that have kept the current model cost effective.
And so the RIAA ends up with only one leg to stand on of the original three. Marketing. It may become the only leg they have, because they aren’t adding value in their old roles. It will be interesting to see how their marketing power and expertise work in a new paradigm of music, if at all. It may be that we will need labels because otherwise we cannot process all of the data we could possibly recieve. It may be that radio stations will become the publishers in the future, or portal web sites, or MTV, or Magazines. Maybe Target or Wal-Mart will be the way we go on this. Or even MP3.com. However, even if it is still the current crop of labels, it is reasonable to surmise that they cannot survive with their current business models.
Keep an eye on the RIAA for the next few years. It’ll be interesting to see which of our elected officials they buy to try to protect their outmoded industry. It’ll be interesting to see if the creative members of the community get the message that Chris Knab has been spreading that they must Adapt or Die.
I don’t know what will come next or how long it will be before we see it, but I am not in favor of propping the labels up. Information was meant to be $10, and most of that should go to the creative types who made it.
| [1]The 1950s-1980 version that was cruelly murdered by Heaven’s Gate, not the pre United States vs. Paramount Pictures et. al. version. Despite Virgin Megastores and Columbia House, the RIAA just can’t control 90% of the buyers like the old MPAA could.
[2]Quality of equipment is an issue, but the existence of cassette tapes is proof that it is not the only factor in popular music appreciation.
[3][ObPlug]Bad or inattentive mastering can ruin any disc. More artists should pony up for pro mastering than do so.[/ObPlug]
[4]This is a really odd phenomena, which differs by musical genre. If I were less lazy, I’d assume there was already a scholarly paper about this very topic on the web and search for it as a reference. Instead I’ll just mention the oddity.
[5]There is still a tax on blank cassette tapes (and consumer music DATs) designed to remunerate the music industry for losses from the thieving public. This is the result of the industry’s previous efforts to protect themselves from new technology.
|
|
| .:Posted by Michael at 05:43 PM
:. |
|
|
|